Family-owned since 2010
An independent agency, run like family.
Tingler Insurance is an independent, full-service insurance agency founded in 2010. We're appointed with — and have access to — many insurance companies, so we can help you find coverage that fits your needs, goals, and budget. As a family-owned agency, we take a personal approach to insurance. Our job is to help protect you, your family, and your business with the same care and attention we'd want for our own.
Our Mission
"To provide great coverage at great rates, with the best personal service."
Our job is to protect you, your family, and your business as if it were our own — with coverage that actually fits, and people who pick up the phone.
One Agency, Many Companies
Why Work With an Independent Agency?
As an independent agency, Tingler Insurance isn't limited to one insurance company. That means we can help you compare options, ask better questions, and find coverage that fits your situation — instead of trying to force everyone into the same policy.
One relationship, several carriers You
Local Roots
A Local Team With Deep Roots
Tingler Insurance is led by a family and team that values relationships, professionalism, and long-term client care. Our team serves individuals, families, and businesses throughout Virginia and Coastal North Carolina.
Ladysmith Office
Bowling Green Office
Rodanthe, NC Office
Meet the Team
The People Behind the Policy
Our experienced team is committed to protecting what matters most. We combine industry knowledge with friendly, personalized service to help you find the right coverage with confidence.
LEE TINGLER
Owner, Principal Agent
With 20+ years of experience in banking and insurance, Lee is licensed in Property & Casualty and Life & Health insurance. He is an award-winning insurance professional dedicated to helping families and businesses protect what matters most.
BETSY TINGLER
Office Manager, Agent
Betsy oversees daily office operations while providing exceptional client support as a licensed Property & Casualty insurance agent. Her background in education and commitment to service help keep the agency running smoothly.
MICKY TINGLER
Agent, Co-owner
Micky specializes in commercial insurance and is a licensed Property & Casualty agent as well as a Certified Builders Insurance Agent (CBIA). His industry expertise helps businesses find dependable coverage tailored to their unique needs.
ANTOINETTE STEPHENS
Office Manager
With 20+ years in the insurance industry and military service in the U.S. Navy, Antoinette is licensed in Property & Casualty and Life insurance. She is passionate about delivering outstanding service and trusted guidance to every client.
DAVID ENGLISH
Agent
David brings extensive experience in engineering, technology, and insurance, along with military service in the U.S. Navy. Licensed in Property & Casualty and Life insurance, he focuses on providing thoughtful advice and personalized coverage solutions.
KELSEY MEADOR
Licensed Client Services Representative
Kelsey is a licensed Property & Casualty insurance professional dedicated to delivering friendly, responsive client support. Her customer-first approach and positive attitude ensure every client receives the attention and care they deserve.
SHERRY TINGLER
Agent
Sherry combines years of experience in real estate, construction, and insurance to help clients make informed coverage decisions. As a licensed Property & Casualty agent, she is committed to providing reliable guidance and exceptional service.
EMMA-LEE MITCHELL
Agent
Emma-Lee brings extensive experience in real estate, business, and insurance to serve clients with confidence. As a licensed Property & Casualty agent, she is dedicated to helping individuals and families secure the right insurance protection.